Imagine you are the leader of a church of around a million and a half people. You are a nationally known (at least among the religious media), you have been interviewed in Newsweek, and widely profiled in the press. It is the last week of Lent. Naturally thoughts are beginning to turn towards Holy Week and Easter. You need to write and Easter message, to be distributed to your churches, and released to the public.
What would you say?
Would you go with the Bishop of Durham’s theme in 2007 and stress the meaning that Christ’s resurrection as a God’s declaration that sin has been judged and that forgiveness is possible and available to all:
in the earliest apostolic proclamation about Jesus of Nazareth his death and resurrection were directly linked to two promises, one about the future, and one about the present. These can be simply stated: the resurrection demonstrates that Jesus is the one ordained by God as judge of the living and the dead, and the resurrection demonstrates that he is the one in whose name forgiveness of sins can be had here and now.
‘God raised him up,’ said Peter to Cornelius, ‘and commanded us to testify that he is the one ordained by God as judge of the living and the dead. All the prophets testify about him that everyone who believes in him receives forgiveness of sins through his name.’
Perhaps you would go with Pope Benedict and stress the meaning of the resurrection as a sign of hope for the future, a reminder that Jesus is alive and that death cannot contain him. A testimony to the fact Christ is not just Lord of the Church but Lord of History, and as such calls for our allegiance and submission to him; at the same time promising us His peace and renewing our hope in his good purposes:
Brothers and sisters in faith, who are listening to me from every part of the world! Christ is risen and he is alive among us. It is he who is the hope of a better future. As we say with Thomas: “My Lord and my God!”, may we hear again in our hearts the beautiful yet demanding words of the Lord: “If any one serves me, he must follow me; and where I am, there shall my servant be also; if any one serves me, the Father will honour him” (Jn 12:26). United to him and ready to offer our lives for our brothers (cf. 1 Jn 3:16), let us become apostles of peace, messengers of a joy that does not fear pain – the joy of the Resurrection.
Maybe you would disavow these time honoured yet well worn paths, and choose instead to break new ground on your own.
Perhaps you would talk about Bovine Methane, or to put it in layman’s terms – cow farts.
You wouldn’t?
I can’t say that I am surprised. But unfortunately this was the approach adopted by Prime Bishop Schori head of the Episcopal Church USA. Her Easter message can be found here. A short statement of just 6 paragraphs, it begins with an exhortation for us all to ask the question:
How can you enact the new life we know in Jesus the Christ? In other words, how can you be the sacrament, the outward and visible sign, of the grace that you know in the resurrected Christ? How can your living let others live more abundantly?
And then unpacks what that might look like, specifically with reference to bovine methane.
We are beginning to be aware of the ways in which our lack of concern for the rest of creation results in death and destruction for our neighbors. We cannot love our neighbors unless we care for the creation that supports all our earthly lives. We are not respecting the dignity of our fellow creatures if our sewage or garbage fouls their living space. When atmospheric warming, due in part to the methane output of the millions of cows we raise each year to produce hamburger, begins to slowly drown the island homes of our neighbors in the South Pacific, are we truly sharing good news?
The food we eat, the energy we use, the goods and foods we buy, the ways in which we travel, are all opportunities — choices and decisions — to be for others, both human and other. Our Christian commitment is for this — that we might live that more abundant life, and that we might do it in a way that is for the whole world.
Now. I’ve been to America several times. I have relatives there and I love it, and it cannot be denied that a lot of Hamburger is consumed there. I’ve no idea how many cows it takes to produce that ‘Hamburger’, and I’m sure that they do fart a lot (the cows, not the Americans… maybe the Americans too). But are they really responsible ‘in part’ (good escape clause there) for slowly drowning the island homes of those poor South Pacificans? And even if they were, what can be done about it? Eat less hamburgers for sure, but is that really what the Gospel message is to be distilled down to in 21st Century America? Is that the best application of the meaning of Christ’s death and resurrection Bishop Schori could come up with after reflecting upon it during the season of lent?
Eat less burgers, so there are less cows producing ‘methane output’, and so in turn Global warming will be a little bit reduced.
Of course it is easy to have fun with another’s sermons.
But there is a serious question to be had here. I currently minister in the Episcopal Church in the Philippines, a church with strong ties to The Episcopal Church in America. And increasingly there is alarm here at the direction The Episcopal Church is taking. Aside from messages of dubious value Bishop Schori’s actions speak loudly. This last week has seen the removal from office of 2 bishops who oppose her and her theological drift. In a meeting whereby The Episcopal Church flouts it’s own Canons repeatedly the Bishops were deposed. Sadly, you might also say criminally, one is an 89 year old servant of the church who’s wife suffers from Alzheimer’s and is by all accounts deeply distressed by the turn of events. (Space precludes much more on this but a good summary is available here, and here, and a tribute to the Bishop Cox, the Bishop in question here).
Is this Bishop Schori’s understanding of the grace that you know in the resurrected Christ?
Cow Farts.
Recent Comments